Why Altcoin Season Peaks But Investors Still Struggle to Profit

by

Okay, buckle up, crypto enthusiasts! The altcoin season is in full swing-yay! But guess what? Most retail investors are still staring at their portfolios like they’ve just opened a bag of stale chips. So, what gives? Let’s unpack this paradox, shall we?

Here’s why your altcoin dreams might not be translating into moon-sized profits:

Altcoin Market Cap is Skyrocketing, But Everyone’s Still Hoarding Their Coins Like They’re Rare Pokémon

According to some super reliable sources (we’re talking TradingView data), the TOTAL3 market cap (aka everything but BTC and ETH) reached a shiny new high of over $1.1 trillion this September. WOOHOO! 🚀

But, hold your horses… the share of “OTHERS” (all the altcoins that aren’t in the top 10) has been dwindling faster than your phone’s battery on a road trip, now at a mere 8% since 2022. #SadFace 😞

Remember 2017 and 2021? The good ol’ days when TOTAL3 and OTHERS.D were like best friends, moving up together in perfect harmony? Well, now it’s like trying to get your dog to get along with the neighbor’s cat-just not happening. The big dogs (SOL, XRP, BNB, DOG, etc.) are getting all the liquidity, while the little guys are like, “Hey, what about us?” 😿

And let’s be real-retail investors tend to throw their money at 25 different altcoins, hoping one of them magically turns into Bitcoin 2.0. Spoiler alert: That doesn’t work.

“Position sizing is everything. Many people hold 25-30 tokens at once. A 100x on a token that makes up only 1% of your portfolio won’t meaningfully change your life. It’s better to make a few high-conviction bets than to overdiversify,” says an analyst who clearly knows more than we do.

Altcoin Index is Soaring, But Investor Sentiment is Like… Meh

We’re at 80 points on the Altcoin Season Index-sounds exciting, right? Over 80% of the top 50 altcoins are outperforming Bitcoin. But guess what? The Fear & Greed Index is sitting at a comfy 52-basically neutral, which is like saying, “I’ll have a glass of water, thanks.” 🥴

In 2024, the Altcoin Season Index and Fear & Greed Index were partying together, reaching record highs. But now? Investors are acting like they’ve been burned before-and honestly, who can blame them? 🤷‍♀️

Perhaps it’s the post-FOMO hangover, or maybe it’s the whole “Fed rate hikes, taxes, and geopolitical chaos” thing. Who knows, but people are cautious. And I get it-nobody wants to repeat their 2017 altcoin regret moment. 😬

“This isn’t an ‘everyone gets rich’ market anymore. It’s player vs. player, especially with the current macro environment,” says another analyst who is way too smart for my taste.

Altcoin Explosion: 21 Million New Tokens Are Here to Ruin Your Life

Okay, so the TOTAL3 market cap is doing its thing, but what about the sheer number of altcoins? In 2025, CoinMarketCap is tracking over 21 MILLION altcoins. That’s… a lot. Like, “How many altcoins can you possibly need?” level of a lot.

In 2021, picking the right altcoin was like finding a decent avocado at Whole Foods-easy peasy. Now? It’s more like sifting through a mountain of crypto tokens to find that one hidden gem, which is… a nightmare. 🥑💩

Guess what? In 2025, it’s going to be even harder to pick the next moonshot token. Because, let’s face it, there are now hundreds of thousands of tokens that will fail faster than you can say “rug pull.” 🍂

“Back in 2021, the altcoin universe was small and almost every coin caught a rally-even the junky ones. Now in 2025, the game has changed. There are hundreds of times more altcoins. With such an oversupply, the odds that your random small-cap will magically 100x are near zero,” says the ever-pessimistic analyst, Nonzee.

So yeah, the market is full of fresh altcoins, and while the overall market might be doing a little happy dance, most investors are probably looking at their portfolios and wondering if they missed the memo. 💃

In conclusion? The altcoin season of September 2025 is kind of like your high school prom-everyone’s talking about it, but not everyone is leaving with a trophy. So maybe do some extra research, focus on quality, and try not to throw your money at every shiny coin that comes your way. 🏆

Read More

2025-09-17 15:42